While John stands as an unorthodox example of an unreliable narrator, considering he does maintain many respectable and trustworthy traits, he is still unreliable, and his pursuit of knowledge is incredibly dangerous. He does show great bravery on his journey eastward, risking his life in the territory of the Forest People, killing a wild panther, crossing the Ou-Dis-Sun really the Hudson Riverand outwitting a pack of wild dogs.
John is the personification of much that is good in humanity. We come to understand the Great Dead Place is actually a futuristic version of New York City, and that somehow our own real and present world must have advanced so rapidly, and with such reckless abandon, that it destroyed itself through war.
Yet the thirst for knowledge exists in John, and he defies the teachings of his father and his people and does in fact travel east.
He even learns to read and is skilled in the practice of medicine. Like the great classical societies in history, New York—and presumably the rest of America, has been completely decimated, and the accumulation of human knowledge lost. Yet as the story unfolds under the first-person perspective of John, the reader is forced to question his credibility as narrator.
Cities will rise and cities will fall. John is not fully reliable as a narrator, and his flaws come from not respecting moderation. He finds the truth he is looking for in The Place of the Gods—a great dead place, which the reader comes to understand as the actual ruins of New York City.
John, while having many respectable and trustworthy traits, is still unreliable in his narration, and the fact he will rebuild society with only a partial understanding of what has really happened in his world implies this new society will be fraught with the same mistakes as its predecessor.
The landscape of the story is that of a desert, with primitive tribes of nomadic peoples scratching out an existence with what food and shelter are left. He is brave, courageous, mature, and hungry for knowledge.
He outlines how anyone, outside of a priest, will surely die if they touch metal—a rule likely originating from the tendency of radiation to manifest itself in metal.
His vision is as alarming as it is poignant, for he witnesses the annihilation of our own world and is compelled to weep.
Benet, however, seems to imply a warning here, for John is so consumed by his new passion to reveal the truth to his people that he will throw caution aside and reject every one of their traditions.
While John admits that too much knowledge at once may have been the bane of the previous society, his ambitious nature suggests he will still rush the rebuilding process.
Set sometime after a total nuclear holocaust, a young man named John sets forth on a journey to discover knowledge about what really happened to his world. In short, the answer is no. John ultimately does come to the realization the gods were men during a powerful vision he has in one of the standing apartment buildings, which he believes to be a great temple.
Fortunately for John, the entire circle of events takes hundreds, if not thousands of years to complete. He cannot contain this desire for the truth. The society that remains has regressed to a savage state.
The fact that John and his people are alive at all is remarkable considering the extent of the nuclear carnage that must have occurred in this world.
There is danger here! How many times will we have to repeat these words? The reader is led to understand how our own world must have destroyed itself through war, and John vividly describes the great Dead Places and the eternal burning that lingers there.“by the Waters of Babylon” vs Epic of Gilgamesh.
Essay Words | 3 Pages “By the waters of Babylon” Vs Epic of Gilgamesh. A lot of stories concerning religions and cultures have lot of similarities and differences, despite the fact that they are not from the same era of. By the Waters of Babylon Questions and Answers - Discover the mi-centre.com community of teachers, mentors and students just like you that can answer any question you might have on By the Waters of.
by the waters of babylon essay THESIS: Benet suggests the cycle of creation and destruction we see in our world is bound to endlessly repeat because of human beings’ limitations in understanding truth. By the Waters of Babylon essaysSteven Vincent Benet, shows all of the different concepts and literary terms in this story.
Some of the concepts and terms he uses are: Sequence, the order events happened in the story to make the ending good; Conflict, amongst John with outside forces; Rites of Passa.
Title: By the Waters of Babylon. Suggested Time:5 days (45 minutes per day) Common Core ELA Standards: RL, RL, RL, RL, RL, RL; W, W, W; SL, SL; L, L, L Teacher Instructions. Preparing for. Teaching. Read the Big Ideas and Key Understandings. Sep 06, · If you misplaced your prompt, I’ve provided it here for you to reference: “Over the course of our short story unit we have read two stories, “By the Waters of Babylon” and “The Pedestrian,” that have used great .Download